Hidden costs of credit-based AI features – A comparison of AI feature pricing for each plugin
- AI billing is divided into three categories.
- The amount of work is more important than the number of credits.
- The prices for each plugin are as follows:
- The most common point where people get stuck when performing calculations manually.
- You can choose based on the amount of work you need to complete.
- Perform basic SEO tasks separately using SOHO SEO.
- Frequently Asked Questions.
- WordPress-related links
Why does the cost sometimes become larger than expected, even after pressing the AI button only a few times? The AI features in the WordPress SEO plugin make it difficult to determine the actual expenditure based solely on the number of credits used.
Even with the same AI support, the amount deducted each time it is used may vary, and unused credits may also disappear. You should also check whether a separate fee is charged for the basic SEO plugin.
You will miss it if you only look at the credits.
AI billing is divided into three categories.
Firstly, the system deducts credits for each task performed. SEOPress AI Credits start at $19 per month and provide 400,000 credits.
Secondly, there is a usage limit system based on function. Rank Math AI sets a separate monthly usage limit for each function, such as long-form content generation and title generation, instead of using credits.
Third, the approach involves incorporating AI features into the basic subscription. Yoast SEO Premium, priced at $118.80 per year, includes AI-powered title and meta description generation, but it has a limit on the number of requests.
If the method is different, the calculation method will also be different.
The amount of work is more important than the number of credits.
The operator is not concerned with whether the credit balance is 400,000. The key question is how many posts can be created per month, how many titles and descriptions can be changed, and how many image alt texts can be generated.
According to SEOPress, a meta title costs approximately 1,600 credits, and a meta description costs approximately 1,800 credits. An image’s alt text, caption, and description cost approximately 3,000 credits, and a single article of approximately 2,000 words costs approximately 15,000 credits.
Therefore, 400,000 credits, based on a simple calculation, corresponds to approximately 26 articles of about 2,000 words each. This explains why the results vary significantly depending on whether only the title and description are created, or whether the article and image are created together.
It’s not about the numbers; it’s about the amount of work.
The prices for each plugin are as follows:
Rank Math AI offers the following annual subscription plans: Starter at €5.99 per month, Creator at €10.99 per month, and Expert at €18.99 per month. The limit for generating long-form articles of 2,000 words is 15 times per month for the Starter plan, 60 times per month for the Creator plan, and unlimited for the Expert plan.
However, the usage limit is reset every month, and any remaining limit does not carry over to the next month. Operators who have months with significantly higher and lower usage may easily miss this condition.
Unused allowance is also a cost.
SEOPress offers 400,000, 1,500,000, and 5,000,000 credits respectively in the $19, $29, and $49 per month tiers. However, to use the AI features, you must also pay the additional cost of SEOPress PRO, which starts at $49 per year per site.
ByTheWeb AI offers 5,000 credits per site per month, priced at $10.95 per month or $9.10 per month with an annual payment. The service details the credit consumption for each feature, such as 450 credits for AI FAQ generation, 50 credits for SEO titles, and 150 credits for SEO descriptions.
Ultimately, the comparison criterion is not the price of a single credit, but the cost of a single task.
The comparison must be made based on the total amount.
The most common point where people get stuck when performing calculations manually.
In reality, the process of creating the spreadsheet often gets stuck. This is because, even when entering 20 posts, 100 meta descriptions, and 80 images, it is not immediately clear how many credits each task consumes.
Furthermore, there are differences in the generated content depending on the length of the text and the model used. For example, if you only create titles in one month, but in the next month you create the main text and images as well, the results will vary even with the same subscription plan.
The workload varies each month.
With SEOPress, 400,000 credits allow for approximately 26 article generations. However, if you include metadata and image generation, the number of articles you can create decreases. If you don’t perform the calculations yourself, you might only focus on the large number of 400,000.
A disadvantage of the credit-based model is that any unused portion may not be carried over to the next billing cycle. In some cases, the AI features may stop working when the credits are used up, which could result in an inability to continue a task at the end of the month.
A flat-rate plan does not necessarily mean that it is unlimited. Yoast SEO Premium does not sell separate AI credits, but there is a limit of a maximum of 3,000 requests per site per month and a maximum of 100 requests per day.
Even with a flat-rate system, there are limits.
You can choose based on the amount of work you need to complete.
If you are an individual operator who relies primarily on the title and meta description in a limited number of posts per month, then a plan requiring less credit calculation is more convenient. In this case, compare Yoast SEO Premium and Rank Math AI first.
Yoast SEO Premium costs $118.80 per year, and the renewal price for Rank Math AI Starter is €83.88 per year. Do not only look at the price; you should also check the monthly request limits and whether the necessary features are included.
If you are an operator who needs to generate large quantities of main text, metadata, and image alt text, the credit-based system, which discloses usage per task, is easier to calculate. Try entering your estimated monthly usage into the 400,000, 1,500,000, and 5,000,000 credit tiers.
If you operate multiple websites, first check the number of websites allowed. While a plan that specifies an unlimited number of websites may seem advantageous compared to a per-site pricing model, a precise comparison requires factoring in the cost of the basic SEO plugin.
The cost of the basic SEO plugin needs to be calculated separately because content generation and website structure management are distinct tasks. SOHO SEO checks and outputs the featured image, title, author, and article structured data, and also manages the sitemap and archive noindex settings. Therefore, it cannot be described as a tool that reduces the number of content generation requests or credits, but it is appropriate to check the scope of technical and structural management as a separate item in the comparison table.
Before making a purchase, please note the following three points:
- Number of posts per month.
- Number of tasks: title, description, and image.
- The sum of the AI costs and the basic plugin costs.
With these three numbers, the comparison can begin.
In summary, if you are only creating titles and descriptions for approximately 10 posts per month, a simpler management system like Rank Math or Yoast is preferable. However, if you are creating a significant amount of content, including text and images, calculate the actual usage based on SEOPress’s task-based allocation and determine the total cost, including the PRO subscription fee.
If you produce less, a simpler method is better.
If a large quantity is produced, the usage amount must be calculated.
Perform basic SEO tasks separately using SOHO SEO.
After calculating the costs of the credit-based and fixed-rate plans, the site’s structure and technical elements must be checked separately. SOHO SEO checks the featured image, title, author, mobile screen, and site icon for each post, and automatically outputs structured data for articles. This feature is not intended to calculate or reduce the number of content generation requests, but rather to separate tasks that are included in basic SEO management.
At the site level, you can enable or disable both the standard XML sitemap and the Google News sitemap for posts within the last 48 hours. You can also apply “noindex” to archives such as those organized by date, author, tags, or search results. Outdated URLs and 404 error pages encountered by visitors can be managed using 301, 302, and 410 redirects. If a site requires this type of structural management, the cost of implementing these features should be included in the base cost estimate, separate from the pricing for content generation features.
Frequently Asked Questions.
Q. Does having more credit always mean a lower price?
A. That is not correct. The number of credits required for each task may vary, and unused credits may not be carried over, so a comparison should be made based on the actual amount of work performed.
Q. Which method is best for my website?
A. If you are only creating titles and descriptions and not writing much content, plans with per-feature limits or basic-included plans are more convenient. If you are creating a large amount of content, including text and images, compare the plans based on the amount of credits deducted per task.
Q. Can this problem be easily solved using a tool? What kind of tool should be used?
A. First, there is a spreadsheet that allows you to enter the monthly workload. By entering the task-specific reduction amount, the number of sites, and the base fee provided by the plugin, it becomes easier to compare the actual costs.
Q. Should the creation costs and the basic SEO management costs be considered separately?
A. Yes. The generation feature’s credit and request limits and the plugin that manages the site structure have different roles, so it is more accurate not to calculate them as the same item. SOHO SEO provides features such as post checks, sitemaps, archive noindexing, and redirects, so try including only the necessary features in the basic cost items.