SEO Score of 100: The Trap – Checklist Scores vs. Actual Rankings
- The 100 points displayed in the editing screen are not search engine scores.
- There is a reason why the score can change even when the text is the same.
- The main reason why your ranking might not improve even with a perfect score of 100.
- Focusing solely on scores can cause you to miss the actual problems.
- Sharing results and insights with SOHO SEO.
- The search performance should be viewed in Search Console.
- So, when should you refer to the 100-point reference?
- Frequently Asked Questions.
- WordPress-related links
When you see a perfect SEO score of 100 and a green light on the editing screen, you can feel relieved. It’s easy to think that it will now appear prominently in search results.
However, it is possible that the number of visitors may not increase even though the score is maxed out. What is missing?
The answer to this question is simple. A score of 100 represents the basic assessment result, not the search ranking.
The 100 points displayed in the editing screen are not search engine scores.
The SEO score displayed in the WordPress editor is not an official score assigned by search engines. It is the result of checking various items defined by the SEO plugin.
We check whether important keywords are included in the title, whether there are any links within the text, and whether a description has been written that will appear in the search results. We also check manageable items such as the address, images, and main titles.
The results for various items are displayed using indicators such as green, orange, and red. This information is then aggregated and presented as a single score.
Therefore, a score of 100 indicates that the page does not omit any essential elements that can be verified. It does not mean that the search engine has promised to rank this page at the top.
Scores and rankings are different.
There is a reason why the score can change even when the text is the same.
The reason this score is attracting so much attention is because the numbers appear very clear. A score of 100 seems better than a score of 72, and a green indicator is more reassuring than a red one.
However, Yoast announced that the analysis criteria have been readjusted in SEO 10.0. This means that even for the same article, the score can change if the criteria are modified or if the article is edited.
This is surprisingly important. It demonstrates that the score is not a fixed quality indicator within the content itself, but rather a value calculated based on the current assessment criteria of a specific tool.
Therefore, it is problematic to definitively conclude that the search value of a document has suddenly improved or worsened based solely on changes in the score. The criteria used by the tool and the actual search results measure different things.
Even if the numbers change, the search intent may remain the same.
The main reason why your ranking might not improve even with a perfect score of 100.
A score of 100 indicates that the basic checks have been passed, but it is not a certificate confirming that success in search results is assured.
Plugins primarily focus on elements that can be visually verified, such as titles, descriptions, and links. In contrast, search engines comprehensively analyze various pieces of information to prioritize content that is reliable and helpful to users.
The scope of the two evaluations is fundamentally different from the beginning. It’s similar to how completing a spelling check before submitting homework doesn’t necessarily mean that the content itself will be beneficial to everyone.
Passing an inspection does not guarantee usefulness.
It is important to be cautious about the idea that longer articles will necessarily rank higher. Google states that there is no magic minimum or maximum number of characters that works.
On the other hand, it does not necessarily mean that a short article is inherently disadvantageous simply because of its length. The important thing is whether the content of the article actually aligns with what the person searching is trying to find.
Even if a website achieves high scores in page experience or other evaluation tools, it does not guarantee a top ranking in search results. Google also explains that it may not be optimal to dedicate all time to achieving a perfect score.
Focusing solely on scores can cause you to miss the actual problems.
When trying to directly achieve a score of 100, the first problem that arises is that the writing becomes unnatural. This can involve repeating keywords excessively or creating titles that are difficult for the reader.
The second problem is that time is wasted on insignificant revisions. Even when a piece of writing is already sufficiently useful to the reader, we keep revising the sentences to remove a single small mark.
A small red light is not a major problem.
The third problem is more significant. It is possible to believe that things are going well based solely on the scores, even when the actual results have worsened.
Google explains that the number of impressions and clicks are more important indicators of success than average ranking. If the number of impressions remains the same but the number of clicks decreases, it is likely that the title or the search result description is not sufficiently persuasive to encourage users to click.
On the other hand, it is not possible to simply blame the content when a website’s ranking declines. There can be various causes, such as algorithm changes, seasonality, changes in search interest, or a website migration.
Here, the specific points where the administrator encounters difficulties become apparent. While the editing screen shows a score of 100, there are few visitors, and it is not clear what needs to be improved.
The method of adjusting each scoring item one by one has clear limitations. This is because the scores do not indicate which search terms the visitor used, how many times the search result appeared, or whether the visitor actually clicked on it.
The cause cannot be determined solely based on the scores.
To resolve issues directly, it is necessary to check the score before publication and the results after publication separately. However, in reality, it is difficult to determine based solely on the display in the editing screen, as it is necessary to compare search terms, exposure and clicks on each page, and site goals together.
Sharing results and insights with SOHO SEO.
When comparing the scores in the editing screen with the results after publication, it is important to manage the technical and structural elements that affect search engine visibility separately before publication. SOHO SEO allows you to check the featured image, title, author, and structured data of a post in one place, and automatically outputs the Article structured data.
If you have checked the HTTPS status and have a configured PageSpeed Insights key, you can also check the mobile loading speed. However, this inspection result does not determine the actual search ranking.
It is also necessary to distinguish between examining the overall structure of the site and the scoring in the editing screen. You can manage both general XML sitemaps and news sitemaps, and you can define the scope of the “noindex” application for archive types pages such as date, author, tags, and search results.
It also separately handles processing old URLs with 301, 302, or 410, recording 404 URLs, and managing candidates for internal posts and external reference links. The sitemap provided by robots.txt and plugins should be checked regularly, and notifications can be received if any issues are detected.
The search performance should be viewed in Search Console.
After publishing, first check the performance report in Search Console. Here, you can see the number of impressions, clicks, click-through rate, search queries, and performance for each page.
Use the score as a checklist before publication, and then the assessment should be based on actual search data after publication. This allows for a distinction to be made between whether a problem lies in the title itself or in the subject matter.
- If there is exposure but few clicks, first examine the title and the search result description.
- If both the number of impressions and clicks are low, check the search query and the page data.
- Next, we review whether the content is relevant to the topic, whether it is original, and whether it is actually helpful.
- The final decision will be based on the goals of the website, such as inquiries, purchases, and subscriptions.
The data determines the direction of the next modification.
For example, if there are impressions but few clicks, there is no need to create a new score of 100. First, it is important to check whether the content that the searcher expects is accurately reflected in the title and description.
If the exposure is limited, it is necessary to examine the search intent and the actual usefulness of the content. This is because there may be a mismatch between what people are searching for and what the content provides.
Ultimately, SEO scores are not numbers to be discarded. However, they should be used not as a report card but as a memo pointing out the basic elements that were missed.
So, when should you refer to the 100-point reference?
If you are managing SEO for the first time, use the scores to check for basic omissions such as the title, description, internal links, and indexability. Do not use a green light or a score of 100 as a condition for publication.
If a webpage is already being displayed in search results, pay more attention to clicks than to the score. If the click-through rate is low, prioritize revising the title and the search result description to better align with the user’s search intent.
If the exposure is low, check the actual search queries and page data in the Search Console. The next step is to re-examine the topic’s relevance, originality, and usefulness.
Here’s a concise summary: 100 points represent the starting point, impressions and clicks indicate progress, and inquiries, purchases, and subscriptions are the final results.
The score is just a starting point.
Do not be complacent about the scores, and do not be anxious because of the scores. Use the numbers only to check the fundamentals, and the next adjustments should be based on actual search performance and business goals.
Frequently Asked Questions.
Q. Can an SEO score of 100 get me to first place in search results?
A. A score of 100 means that the plugin has verified that certain on-page elements meet the required criteria. However, this score does not guarantee first place or high placement in search results.
Q. What should I fix first on my website?
A. If there is exposure but few clicks, first review the title and the search result description. If the exposure itself is low, check the search queries and page data in the Search Console, and then verify the relevance of the topic and content.
Q. Can this problem be easily solved using a tool? What kind of tool should be used?
A. SEO plugins can help ensure that no essential elements are overlooked. However, to accurately assess the actual results, it is necessary to use data from Search Console, including impressions, clicks, search queries, and page-specific data.
Q. When search rankings do not improve, should I start by changing the SEO plugin?
First, in Search Console, check the impressions and clicks for each keyword and page, and carefully examine the technical and structural elements for any omissions.
SOHO SEO can be used to check the structured data and featured image of posts, as well as to manage sitemaps, the noindex setting for archive pages, and redirections and 404 addresses. These features do not replace search performance data, so it is important to view both types of information together.